67 Comments
User's avatar
Brigid LaSage's avatar

Ah yes, but there's a method to this madness: ".. a critique of American history and contemporary American society that portrays the country as racist at its core and controlled by a club of self-interested billionaires." This effectively delegitimizes our Constitution and paves the way for the revolution that the overeducated and resentful "vanguard" has wanted all along. They keep saying "By any means necessary." Believe them.

Lis's avatar

I am sorry, but I don't agree that Trump continuously calls this a failure of a nation. He practically wraps himself in the American flag every day. I don't see anything but a love for our country in everything he does. But then, I'm a Republican patriot, so maybe I see things differently.

John Olson's avatar

It is inconceivable to any sane person that a President who is not patriotic would publish an edition of the Bible with the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the lyrics to "God Bless The USA" in the appendix. Trump did.

Chance Groom's avatar

A tacky money making scheme is not patriotism.

John Olson's avatar

To the best of my recollection, you are the first person I have ever heard describe the King James Bible, the Declaration of Independence, and the U.S. Constitution as "tacky."

Teed Rockwell's avatar

What’s tacky is putting all three of these documents in the same volume, and then putting Trump’s name on it.

Chance Groom's avatar

You must not look outside your own political sphere if I'm the only person you have ever heard calling a Trump merchandised Bible selling for $60 to $100 with hideous gold trimming as tacky https://godblesstheusa.com/?srsltid=AfmBOoogYBPrdj9aJiSxy5JZ3CWt6kndGW693DGdZptb06O8Tfpv5P7I

John Wygertz's avatar

You complain about Trump calling America a "failing nation". When only 27% of Democrats are proud to be American, something is indeed failing.

Cal Lawrence's avatar

That something being that the Republican Party has thoroughly destroyed America.

John Wygertz's avatar

Sure has. Armed security in churches, Plexiglass covers on store shelves, combination locks on restrooms in public buildings, homeless zombies everywhere, boys in girls' bathrooms.... Damn those Republicans.

Cal Lawrence's avatar

Those are all the delusional fantasies that Trump sold you to get your vote.

John Wygertz's avatar

Maybe where you are, I lived in it every day until I moved away from Portland. Trump didn't sell me on anything, but I appreciate the closed border.

Mike McNamee's avatar

The partisan difference:

Trump may have described the 2016 and 2024 situations as hellscapes, but his declared aim is to “Make America Great AGAIN.” There’s a great nation there waiting to be reclaimed.

Democrats’ response: “What makes you think America has ever been great?” As Michelle Obama put it, they can only be proud of the nation when they’re in charge.

I think it’s difficult to accuse both sides of an equal lack of patriotism.

Bob Eno's avatar

I notice that, like the Liberal Patriot Substack, the comments here seem overwhelmingly to be devoted to attacks on Democrats and the Democratic Party. I'm here because I'm a liberal and I hope liberals on both the Left and Right are welcome here.

I'm a liberal on the Left and I see myself as patriotic. If I were asked whether I'm proud of my country -- Yes or No -- I'd have a very difficult time answering. I grew up and remain proud of the American tradition. I didn't have to wait for contemporary progressives to point out the deep injustices of slavery: Jim Crow (both de jure in the South and de facto in the North) was alive and well when I was young during the Eisenhower years and I found it a conundrum that it could exist in a country founded on the proposition that all men were created equal. In that sense, my pride was qualified by what I knew, but it was pride nonetheless. I opposed and was active in opposing the Vietnam War during the Johnson and Nixon years; I felt it was inconsistent with American values in multiple respects -- I was angry at American conduct but proud of the American tradition that allowed me to express that anger and convinced that in the long term Americans would correct course (as I saw that course).

I have lived and worked for years outside the US, but it is inconceivable to me that I would ever shift my permanent home or national allegiance away from America. But I have felt anger and shame at some choices administrations have made for seventy years, and I consider my freedom to say so, and to actively support those with whose views align with mine, as part of the promise that makes America great and to which I feel deepest loyalty.

So how should I answer the Yes/No question of the pollster? I'm a liberal and what makes me proud to be an American is the liberal core of its Constitution. I'm furious at illiberal forces in my country, on the far Left from those I view as ideologues, who take part for whole in seeing America's story as only a list of its failures and who seek to overturn the liberal core, and on the Right, from those who celebrate or whitewash those failures and demand that we still our awareness of them, license whatever actions come draped in our flag, attack those who take exception as "unpatriotic" when dissent is a core feature of the American body politic, and tell the pollster Yes, Yes, Yes, no matter what course our country is pursuing.

I think the question should not be whether we are proud of America -- that should depend on our individual judgments of what America does. It should be whether we love America, which depends on what America is. I will always love America, regardless of which political party prevails at any given time. But I will be proud of it, yes or no, only according to my own judgment, as befits a liberal state. As for being "proud to be an American," the answer will always be "No." I feel lucky to be an American. It is an unearned gift -- I was born here. I don't believe one should ever be proud of a gift one has not earned. My great-grandparents had the right to be proud: they risked all of the little they had to bring their families here and they earned their American citizenship.

Michael Baharaeen's avatar

Thanks for your thoughtful comment, Bob. There's a Mark Twain quote I'm fond of that might resonate with you: "Patriotism is loving your country all the time, and your government when it deserves it." I take a couple of things from this. First, a country is so much more than its government. It's the people, culture, traditions, social mores, and history (yes, the good and the bad). Second, this view shifts the question from "pride in country" to "love of country." I can understand how people may see actions by the government they disapprove of (starting wars, mistreating its citizens, etc.) and respond with waning pride in their country. But that doesn't mean they have to stop loving it.

I worry that Ruy is right when he says that for many Democrats, love of country has become contingent on whether their views and preferred policies are the ones being represented and implemented at the top levels of government. I have seen far too many liberals go beyond despair in the second Trump term and engage in outright self-loathing at their American identity. Simultaneously, there are some forces on the far left advancing a more sinister view of the U.S. as a violent, oppressor nation with no redeeming qualities that needs to be torn down entirely (this is essentially the stated view of the DSA, which is, alarmingly, finding a home in the Democratic Party). And the waning love of country in mainstream Democratic circles has created fertile ground for some version of this darker view to spread.

Of course, I reject the ascendant view on the far right that argues American identity isn't rooted in loyalty to shared values but rather in a specific (European) heritage. But it is true that their love of country has not wavered in recent history, no matter which political party is in charge. I think that is something Democrats would be wise to reflect on.

Bob Eno's avatar

Thanks for this great response, Michael. I'm in full agreement with your alarm at the ascent of the DSA and its influence among some elements within the Democratic Party. And, to be clear, it's not because the DSA is "socialist" -- I think traditional socialism offers a range of constructive approaches that a country committed to free-market principles can adapt (as even an arch-reactionary like Bismarck recognized) -- it's because I think it's perversely dogmatic. For me this is not new. When I marched against the war in the '60s I was disillusioned to discover the narrow ideological extremism of some movement leaders. Eugene McCarthy's campaign provided a constructive path for me, but I see in the groups I left behind then the lineage leading to today's DSA.

However, I can't agree with your thought that the extreme Right has always loved America. The factions that view America today through the lens of books like "The Turner Diaries" or "The Camp of the Saints" (or what they're told about that nearly unreadable book) see today's America with distaste just as radical as any DSA member's, but they claim to love a former America that they are fighting to restore -- an America based on the creed that "all heritage American people are created equal -- and others poison the blood." Calling this "patriotism" is a caricature of the true idea because it rejects American first principles. It is the patriotism of the coup. It's precisely because those on the extreme Right wrap themselves in the flag that the liberal Left has become so averse to waving the flag.

There was an era I remember when people of the mainstream Right and Left were constructive adversaries in a dynamic where each side worked to discern and correct the excesses of the other, generally sharing commitment to first principles through periods of stronger and weaker disagreement on the ways to realize them. I think that dynamic was terrifically fruitful and that's what I'd like to return to. And I actually see the splashy extremisms on Left and Right becoming so tiresomely dogmatic that it may create an opening for actual liberals on the Left and Right to realize that they not only share first principles, but that together they constitute the great majority of Americans, and can represent them if they can work together to foreground opposing visions of a single American ideal.

Michael Baharaeen's avatar

I should clarify: I think the far right's view of America is odious, but I would make a distinction between their view and that of mainstream conservatives/Republicans (who are broadly represented in the Gallup polling Ruy cites). I realize it may have sounded like I was saying the *far right* has always loved America, and I would agree with you that that is not the case.

Freedom Lover's avatar

You are based on the above, a patriot. Many of the elected Democrats today really are not.

Bob Eno's avatar

I would strongly disagree. I think almost all elected Democrats feel love for their country, pride in its principles, keen discomfort at its past failures, and alarm at its current direction. I can think of a few who, judging from statements I saw highlighted by the press, may be exceptions. I do recognize that there are visible and loud *un*elected people who tend to vote Democratic or third-party who, because they are on the Left, are often mistaken for members of the Democratic Party, and whose statements seem so hostile to America's broadly liberal tradition that they truly feel no love for America as a home and tradition.

There is a famous saying you probably know: "Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel." In the view of many on the liberal Left the performative patriotism that they see on the Right -- just think of the literal flag-hugging by President Trump or the white nationalist cooptation of the term in groups such as the Patriot Front -- demonstrates the truth of that saying, and they are uncomfortable with the displaying the conventions of patriotism. I certainly am.

(I should add: when I speak of "almost all elected Democrats," I'm passing over the fact that I believe a percentage of elected officials of both parties equally are not actually much committed to public service in the spirit of patriotism. They talk the talk but are basically unprincipled and out for themselves. I think that's pretty much a given for a portion of the political leadership class in every country. Of course, political office is a paid job with pleasures of public success: self-interest is part of every office holder's mix; it's a matter of degree in commitment to the public interest as well.)

Freedom Lover's avatar

I don't know what they feel in their hearts. All I know is what they say and do. And they are pandering to the portion of their base that thinks the United Srates is a bad place and bad country. We all have eyes and ears and we see and hear. And I am not a Republican and most certainly not a supporter of Trump who gives patriotism a bad name.

Bob Eno's avatar

I think this is a thoughtful reply, Freedom Lover. But my sense is that the pandering (to use your term) is largely related to positions on progressive priority issues, rather than to far Left views of American history and traditions. Americans who feel no love of America may still advocate for positions that political actors who do love America may see as constructive and ones they can accommodate. There are, however, limits to how far this can go without essentially being coopted by the far Left in a desire to win their votes, and my guess is that you and I may differ as to where those limits lie.

TruthCanHurt23's avatar

This is marvelously well-said. My (disturbingly) less thoughtful version, after (also disturbingly) inadequate deliberation, was this:

1. I'm extremely proud of the American citizenry, and proud to be part of it.

2. I'm extremely proud of America's charter, and of its contributions to humanity over 250 years. Warts and all, no other country since the Roman Republic comes close.

3. I'm extremely alarmed by how utterly awfully our governments have performed the past decade. We're on an unsustainable course in many respects, and nearly 100% of it can be attributed to our two legacy parties, who have held our government and our political system captive to their holy war.

This is the glass we need to break: the parties are strangling the life out of American self-government, by unhesitatingly stramrolling the Constitution or rule/spirit of the law for short-term political gain.

It's not sustainable, and it looks like the citizenry will need to stop it, since the parties are only accelerating their pace of damage.

Sadredin Moosavi's avatar

I see where you are going with this but disagree with the assessment. When Tucker Carlson objects to the "Epstein class" he is not being unpatriotic to America but criticizing an element within its population that has earned the questions it is receiving. Similarly, Trump's attempts to show respect for what is good in America would be considered pretty standard patriotism if any other president had done the same things on their watch. This suggests that the patriotism problem really is on the Democrat side ONLY. Part of the problem with Democrats as a group is that they incorrectly assume that the positions they hold automatically represent the dominant and "correct" position on the topic in question. This is demonstrably false on many, some might argue, most topics today. Until Democrats recognize that THEY have strayed from the center on these issues, there is little reason to believe they will regain majority support in the country. Trying to hide this behind "what about-ism" on Republicans and Independents isn't going to work.

David Foster's avatar

"Donald Trump won the Republican nomination in 2016 by framing the U.S. as a nation in terminal decline"....the phrase 'terminal decline' would imply that the decline cannot be reversed. Trump won largely because he asserted that the decline *could* be reversed.

While Obama mocked the idea of doing substantially more manufacturing in the United States (I think the phrase 'magic want' was used), Trump has undertaken initiatives to make it happen. You might not think that these are the best ways to do it, or even viable ways, but I don't see how you can doubt that that is the intent.

Chance Groom's avatar

Jos Biden had more coherent and substantive manufacturing policy than Obama and both Trump terms yet gets almost no credit. https://cepr.net/publications/the-biden-boom-and-trump-slump-a-serious-comparison-of-the-two-economies/

Freedom Lover's avatar

Thats because he didn't really have anything. His administration was run by unelected unaccountable and largely unknown "advisers."

Cal Lawrence's avatar

Donald Trump created the decline by getting elected and destroying evertyhing.

Frak's avatar

Yeah... I remember when Hillary Clinton tried that same schtick in 2016, trying to say that 'since Trump said America had bad problems that meant Republicans didn't love America, but actually America was pretty great!'

This was stupid for two extremely obvious reasons: #1, nobody with two brain cells to rub together thought Hillary actually believed this and they certainly didn't either, and #2, Americans DO think this country has some severe issues facing it, which is exactly why the DSA is ascendent within the ranks of liberalism, because they've tried since 2008 to get ANYBODY in the Dem establishment to hear them.

Trying to "both sides" us with this ain't it guys. I get the Democratic Party is dead, and no one in Washington appreciates it, but classic neoliberal smarm where you push disingenuous nonsense that lies about both sides to an audience who is simply more sophisticated than that isn't going to get you anywhere on your quest to rebuild said dead party. Republicans and their politicians are demonstrably patriotic, the liberal thought leaders to be found in and on college campuses, the New York literary circuit, and MSNOW obviously don't have that much love for the country and are quite willing to explicitly say so.

Again, this ain't it.

Ronda Ross's avatar

Patriotism is difficult when one side views 1/2 the US as permanently irredeemable. This summer, my husband's golf addiction landed us in Norway's Arctic Circle. 3 hours past an airport with only a handful of gates, and few hours from the end of life, as most humans know it.

Preparing for an Icelandic pony trail ride, we encountered a rare other US family. The world being a small place, our husbands attended the same grad school, at the same time, in different disciplines. The other Mother and I shared the same profession, each with 1 college kid in tow. PLUs- people like us, must have been the assumption.

As we saddled up, the other Mother turned to our German college girl guides, and expressed her gratitude and amazement all Scandinavians had been so friendly. She feared they would spend weeks as ostracized Americans, thanks to Trump and his idiot sycophant followers destabilizing the world.

One guide nodded, and then turned to our son and mouthed "what is she talking about?". My husband, who is not overly political, but a youngest child troll by birth, was on the verge of comment, when I discreetly kicked his shin. I smiled and mumbled to my horse.

I kept mumbling, as she explained, while viewing some of the most gorgeous and unique scenery on earth, the US was sure to be permanently felled by an 80 year old Queens builder and his idiot Flyover followers. At one point my husband whispered he would take one for the team and launch himself down the rocks and into the 40 degree ocean below, but for his impending tee time.

Mercifully, eventually, the ride ended. They headed to their next destination. We convinced the only bar in 30 minutes to open early.

None of this is remotely normal. Despite the MAGA myth, most Americans are mostly lukewarm or moderately cool regarding most US politicians. The hostility directed at supporters now, is a different level of mass division. Ask political junkies how many times the word "uneducated " was utilized in political speak, pre Trump. The answer is rarely. We once separated voters by white or blue collars. We did not label one side ignorant. Patriotism, in that situation, is nearly impossible.

Marlene Barbera's avatar

Quality comment.

Next time unleash your husband.

Restraint, is why they assume widespread agreement with their childish and vituperative worldview.

Cal Lawrence's avatar

Donald Trump is not a “Queens builder”, he’s a career con artist.

He and his MAGA cult are permanently irredeemable, but there’s nowhere near being ½ of the country.

Ebenezer's avatar

I think it would be helpful if we zoomed out from US history to world history. Slavery, for example, was far from a uniquely US evil. Less than 5% of the Transatlantic Slave Trade went to the US. And if you look at African-Americans today, they are far better off (in terms of income, education, life expectancy) than they would've been if their ancestors stayed in West Africa.

A lot of the anti-patriotism stuff comes from comparing the US to a hypothetical perfect country which doesn't exist. Knowing more about world history helps bring perspective.

Marcia Gorham's avatar

Bill Maher: “Being woke is like a magic moral time machine in which you judge everyone by what you think you would have done in 1066, and you always win,” Maher said, adding that presentism is “just a way to congratulate yourself about being better than George Washington because you have a gay friend and he didn’t.”

Stephan Edwards's avatar

I suppose it won't make me any friends here when I say the Democratic Party makes it pretty plain they hold Patriotism & anyone who claims to be a Patriot in open contempt. "Inherently Racist" ring any bells? Maybe "Jim Crow 2.0"?

The fact is the Democratic Party comes off has more interested and the Party of Mexico, El Salvador, Haiti rather than a Party of the US or representing US voter's interests. Witness their support of "Free Trade" no matter it's effect on the Working Class or the Private Sector Unions they purport to support.

All the Democrats said was "How wonderful this agreement will be for the people of...." Their own voter's? Who cares?

And people start pointing fingers... I've never voted GOP in my life. But I'd rather vote for a Dancing, Singing Purple Dinosaur than any candidate offered in the last 30+ years.

I've given up on voting and withdrawn because the Candidates aren't worth voting for and nothing will change anyway. A plague on both Houses.

John Olson's avatar

Michelle Obama said she was never proud of her country until her husband was elected to the Senate. Can you imagine Laura Bush making an anti-patriotic remark like that? Can you imagine Billy Graham shouting "God damn America!" from the pulpit? The Obamas' pastor, Jeremiah Wright, did exactly that. Even after Al Sharpton promoted the Tawana Brawley gang rape hoax, the Democrats let him run for President in their primary. The Democrats are so scared of being called racist by any black celebrity that they tolerate anti-patriotic remarks, even inexcusable frauds, from black Democrats.

Zac Hill's avatar

Another big downside of this 'yes, but' orientation is that it positions Democrats as the party of neuroticism. We always seem to be the kind of people who can put together five-bullet-pointed critiques of things, but not actually accomplish important results (e.g. urban governance, but also e.g. lowering costs).

Democritus's avatar

That's because current progressive methods don't work so well. Compare CA's situation with TX's.

Cal Lawrence's avatar

TX is a shithole. People move there because housing is cheap, then after living there they realize why it’s so cheap. Living in a shithole is cheaper than living somewhere decent.

Zac Hill's avatar

That is one of the dimensions of the problem, for sure. But another is that *even when things work reasonably effectively*, as with e.g. the transformation of municipal DMVs over the last ~10-15 years, Democrats don't *convey they impression* of being effective leaders that can get things done efficiently.

Democritus's avatar

Agreed. Oregon's Department of Fish and Wildlife works like a well oiled machine. Very user friendly and always helpful. Maybe that's because hunters and fisherman aren't overwhelmingly blue. That's probably a reach on my part.

Democritus's avatar

I would say that the party out of power is less patriotic. The Dems now dislike our country and would like to see failure so they can get back in power. Recently read in a major newspaper:

"So much is going politically right for Democrats these days. President Trump’s approval is down, gas prices are up and an unpopular war with Iran drags on. But dysfunction and debt inside one of the party’s key institutions — which is getting crushed in fund-raising by its Republican counterpart — are creating rising anxiety for top Democrats. "

I find that the R's are more patriotic. If the D's regain power, the R's will be less happy with what's going on. The R's like the idea of blue places going under (LA) so it will be proof that blue policies don't work. That's certainly true in my city, Portland, failure of the blue. But I think that most of my generation has been criticizing our country since Viet Nam, and that criticism has taken hold with following generations, academia, and blue state and local governments.

ban nock's avatar

I notice things flag make some on the left uneasy, I have one in front of my house which is on the main drag. The guy across the street who is a great guy though of the other team politically also has one in a flag pole no less and often flies other flags beneath, Gadsden, state flag, etc. I use his flags as a weather vane all the time. Wind out of the east with the smell of the stockyards means watch out.

I'd like to see something similar to the selective service again. Some sort of mandatory service for just about everyone.

Marcia Gorham's avatar

Sunny Hostin (The View,) made the comments about feeling unsafe around excessive displays of American flags. I've heard other Democrats say the same. Haven't heard of a Republican saying it though...

Matt Goodwin's avatar

We are living through the greatest radicalisation of the elite class since the 1960s. Elites are moving Left as millions of ordinary people are moving Right.