23 Comments
User's avatar
Tim's avatar
4hEdited

Isn’t it interesting that while “Affordability” was a key message (just what that means was never defined) there are no proposals to rein-in spending to impact the deficit and debt. Instead, it gets implemented through “we’ll give you more money AND pay for all these things” and ignore what that will do to the dangerous financial situation we face and will force even higher inflation with all the spending. They learned NOTHING during Biden’s years. While I will hate to have to endure all the histrionics, I sure hope they get bogged down with endless investigations and “gotcha” pursuit. STOP spending our money!

holly.m.hart's avatar

Stop spending borrowed money that future generations will have to repay! Both parties have been doing this. It is the easy way for them to please their constituents and get elected.

Hal's avatar

Spot-on commentary - thanks!

Richard's avatar

This article highlights the eternal tension between doing something significant and being popular. Machiavelli identified the problem 500 years ago and the dynamic hasn't changed. Affordability was very popular but beyond practical problems, it is incremental and boring. It doesn't satisfy the desire to profoundly remake the country. As an example not otherwise mentioned, the incoming Governor of Nevada is calling for the abolition of the Electoral College because it's racist. It is going to take extraordinary discipline to stay focused on the issue that won the election. Do the Democrats have it? Teixeira knows better than me but it looks like his assessment is No.

Frak's avatar

I would agree with the far left that bold action is required. Overreach may be a danger, but it's certainly not more of a danger than underreach. If the Democrats put up some monoparty candidate in 2028, and I don't look for the establishment to lose control of the Democratic Congress here in upcoming leadership elections, they'll be trounced by a Sears mannequin wearing a red tie in that Presidential election if Trump puts his arm around it.

The problem for liberals is they're stuck between two kinds of stupid: one who thinks things should forever be left the way they are as a one bedroom ranch home slowly inches its way toward an average national price of $10,000,000, and China just goes ahead and takes possession of our universities, media, internet, and provides a decent number of political and civic leaders with their mistresses, and the other who think they can still salvage 2019 if they just double down on being racist, sexist, xenophobic, and generally hateful THE RIGHT WAY, while instituting Communism but for real this time.

I wouldn't put it past that radical left to actually do some good if not for their inescapable instinct to try to fix every problem by throwing more money at it. The only realistic way to make universal healthcare work would be to first have independent white blood cells investigate the American healthcare system and find all the ways you can make it cheaper and control the costs into the future. But their system, complete with no shortage of grifting, nepotism, open corruption, NGO giveaways, and worse, would certainly do just the opposite, creating a public healthcare system that cost more than ever while delivering less than ever.

And, I really don't want to leave out that Obama was polled as low as 37% approval in November of 2014, while Rasmussen has Trump at 41% today, so.... yeah. I would kinda sorta quite pretending that the Trump voters who didn't show up to vote in the midterms agree with liberals about literally anything from DOGE to ICE to Iran.

Brent Nyitray's avatar

They will just impeach Trump a couple dozen times and call it a day.

Robert Litan's avatar

100% right, am especially worried that in a very crowded 28 field, the most obvious "progressive" candidate, AOC if she chooses to run, will win the nomination -- and lose badly to any number of Rs, and reverse much or all of the gains Ds just made in the mid-terms. Trump, after all, won in a fractured primary in 16.

Petey Kay's avatar

Who in their right mind voted for these people?

Aryan Nezamabadi's avatar

Something I haven’t seen discussed much is what progressives actually mean by “Medicare for All,” which has very little to do with current Medicare. Jayapal’s and Sanders’s bills would create a fully socialized healthcare system with no out-of-pocket costs and a benefits package that goes beyond what is offered by virtually any country with universal healthcare.

The bills create the role of regional healthcare administrator, tasked with determining the annual “budget” for every hospital, dialysis center, SNF, LTACH, surgical center, etc., and then distributing lump-sum payments to these facilities quarterly. As far as I understand, no “profit” would be allowed, and private capital expenditures would be banned. The only source of new capital for building healthcare facilities would be public funding, allocated at the discretion of the regional healthcare director, who is appointed by the Secretary of Health.

Doctors would be paid on a fee-for-service basis and would essentially be allowed to order anything, since coverage criteria determined by the Secretary of Health would be mere suggestions. These criteria would simply appear as notifications in the EMR, which doctors could override based on “physician judgment” or even “patient preference.”

Payments for physician services would be based on rates determined by the regional director. Physicians could technically choose not to participate in the public healthcare program and instead charge patients privately. However, if they did so, they wouldn’t be allowed back into the public program for two years. I’m not sure whether that means two years from the time they leave the program or two years from the last time they privately charged for any care.

This would make the proposed system far more socialized and comprehensive than most universal healthcare systems around the world.

Tim's avatar

Yep. Tried in VT in 2014…with control of their gov, senate and house. Realized it would essentially double state budget. Went nowhere. Similar in MD (I believe it was MD). Same outcome. And there are a number of states with all 3 levels held by D’s. If it was workable would have happened by now. It needs fixing, but their cries for single payer, covering all, and free just can’t happen. But it sure makes for great sound bites for those getting their news and opinions from TikTok, etc.

Bill L's avatar

It will be quite popular if progressives can fake the numbers enough to convince voters that “the rich,” oligarchs, corporations, unicorns, the Easter Bunny, or some other iteration of Notyou and Notme will pay for it all.

The problem, as the British NHS has found, is that taking every dime from Notyou and Notme won’t cover the enormous cost of universal healthcare and voters aren’t willing to tax themselves nearly enough to pay for the level of service they have been promised, so services slowly deteriorate due to lack of funds.

Dental care in Britain is now de facto private pay even though it’s covered by NHS, because the reimbursement rates don’t allow dentists to make a living so they refuse to accept NHS patients (and nobody needs dental care more than the English).

Christopher Lynch's avatar

As always, great analysis and great writing.

I think the great experiment with letting "the people" pick the candidates is a failure.

Bill L's avatar

The experiment was begun by insurgent Democrats who were angry that party leaders nominated Hubert Humphrey instead of Eugene McCarthy in 1968. Humphrey lost in ‘68 but George McGovern, the first candidate nominated by “the people,” lost in ‘72 by one of the greatest landslides in American history.

Douglas Levene's avatar

Indeed, I would be delighted to return to candidates chosen by party professionals with a couple of primaries thrown in for color.

Raul Zavaleta's avatar

My fear is that their #1 goal will be, not developing policies that may help the country, but how to assure that the party continues to win in the future (pack the court, abolish the electoral college) and get revenge on the opposition.

Benjamin Heinrich's avatar

I think the Democrats will bicker internally over whatever we have open borders basically DSA, and Joe and Jane Congressperson from New York and California who's states are shrinking in population with a census coming in a few years and need illegal immigrants to avoid their states losing reps and therefore their districts losing tax dollars or having to run a primary against another Democrat or have another primary challeger from the DSA, and the newly elected Senators and Reps from swing or red districts who knows a repeat of Bidens border policy means they lose reelection. Talarico is woke but he genuinely doesn't want a repeat of Bidens border policy because it means he loses reelection in 2032. The border will essentially be like the a married couple arguing over the thermostat if the Democrats take power again in 2028.

George Phillies's avatar

So what will the over-reaches be? At a guess, some of the following

Amnesty for all current illegal residents.

Forgiveness for college student loans

Banning semiautomatic (one trigger pull, one round fired) rifles and/or their magazines.

Expanding the Supreme Court.

Failing to release the Epstein papers

Failing to prosecute corrupt politicians and their corrupt relatives.

Your mileage may vary as to whether some of these are overreach.

Douglas Levene's avatar

Mr. Teixeira is correct, of course, on all particulars, but I fear the only consequence for being right is whatever pleasure he might find in saying “I told you so” after the next election

Algo Mas's avatar

Interesting overview....even though I disagree with much of it. Let the last 100 years be your guide. Moderately close examination shows Democrats as agents of change and better leaders who can actually govern. Generalizing??? Sure as hell am. Democrats are builders and the GOP tears things down. There are countless examples. They aren't called the Party of "no" for no reason. I am one who believes "culture wars" are something Ron Desantis blabs about and few others (except Republicans) even think about. How many transgender kids/people are there? Not very many. Well, lookie here...the entire MAGA dialogue was short circuited and that's why the GOP lost. Hopefully they will learn their lesson.

Nick's avatar

Feel free to explain to us what the democrats have “built” in the last 20 years.

Douglas Levene's avatar

They probably will but if you are any indication, the Democrats will not.

Algo Mas's avatar

The people I supported were, unanimously, winners in both my home State and elsewhere. The Chump regime seems like a bad fever dream. Many saw this coming. You probably have trouble ordering from a menu.

Morris Fiorina's avatar

For an earlier statement of this argument, see Morris Fiorina, Unstable Majorities: Polarization, Party Sorting & Political Stalement, 2017, especially Chapter 5, The Temptation to Overreach.