There is much logic in this piece. I also agree that Democrats have MORE work to do here in the end than Republicans do. Like it or not, Donald Trump will not be on the ballot again and Democrat's focus on dislike of Trump personally will NOT overcome their being wrong on many of the issues that actually matter to the median voter.
You discount ideology. Both parties have prioritized that over winning by convincing themselves that the majority aligns with their ideology. The wipeout of the Blue Dogs in the Obamacare election (2010) is an example. The prospect for governance lies in populist fusion to actually solve some problems rather than having the Establishment use the problems for fund raising and then fail to act on solving them.
I don't think the midterms meant anything more, to most voters, than a general tiredness with Trump. Except to the progressives, the midterms did not mean a vote for a massively more active government.
This does not mean that the progressives won't push for their agenda over the next two years. They want to impeach Trump and Hegseth; they want to withdraw immediately from Iran; they want to place a moratorium on data centers and the creation of a government agency to regulate AI; they want universal health care and increased taxes to pay for it; they want to return to DEI and guarantee transgenderism, including allowing surgery for minors; they want to abolish ICE and put a stop to deportations; they want to expand the Supreme Court and eliminate the Electoral College; and so on.
A majority of Americans don't want all this. Most of what the progressives want they won't get, and the more they push their agenda, the stronger the reaction will be. Trump will continue being the President for the next two years and he will not be shy about using the veto.
The clincher will be the Presidential election in 2028. If the progressives push for AOC and she is nominated, the Republicans will win the election. It looks now as if Rubio will be the nominee for the Republicans and he will win. He will not rule like Trump did but more like Reagan did.
Mr. Roeder, I think your second paragraph mixes "progressives" with center-liberal Democrats. The latter would probably want to impeach Hegseth, withdraw from Iran, and create a regulatory agency vis a vis AI. They may also want to reform the Supreme Court (perhaps by expansion, depending on the specific plan) and, of course, abolish the Electoral College, perhaps through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which obviously already has very broad support. (The AI moratorium movement is currently far more of a popular response than one owned by any political faction of either party. I also think that it's unlikely there will be a move to impeach Trump a third time unless and until he acts so flagrantly that conviction appears likely.)
The specifically progressive policies in your list would include universal health care (assuming you mean immediate Medicare-for-All; center-liberal Democrats are obviously in favor of moving towards universal coverage to the degree possible with fiscal integrity) and a return to maximalist DEI. I have no idea what "guaranteeing transgenderism" may mean apart from allowing surgery for minors, but I do think progressives own certain activist positions, such as permitting trans women to compete in women's sports.
I think it's likely that the positions of the Democratic liberal Center currently would be well received by a majority of voters. I think DEI and support for extreme trans medical and social policies would be poison pills for the party. (Less so Medicare-for-All, which I believe could become broadly popular if a plan to phase it in made explicit the trade-offs between necessary higher taxation and relief from private/employer insurance plan costs, and if options for supplementary private plans were allowed as part of an indefinitely long transition.)
From where I sit now, I agree that Rubio would probably win a presidential election against AOC in 2026. Both will be modifying their political profiles over the next two years, and the political winds will shift in ways none of us can predict, so I'm not sure about 2028. I think that among the dozen best known Democratic candidates, well over half are, at this time, better positioned than any known GOP hopeful to win a general election. AOC is currently not the leader in polls of Democratic party member preferences, and I believe that while she has a sizable base of support, candidates more capable of unifying the party are less subject to hitting a hard ceiling below 50% (obviously, Ossoff is currently the model, but I believe others with better chances of reaching party majority support would include Buttigieg, Kelly, Shapiro, the shape-shifting Newsome, among others.
"It certainly moves the ideological center of gravity of our national politics to the left some, but it actually moves the internal ideological centers of gravity of both parties to the right."
I think this is exactly right. In terms of 2028 electoral promise, I believe this will strongly handicap the extreme Left of the Democratic Party--as the DSA seems to have recognized, with dismay--and may strengthen the Groyper-associated wing of the GOP--which is what Fuentes and his supporters seem to believe, with pleasure.
The size of the Democratic wave in Texas and the tremendous rise in influence that this huge state will now have in the party caucus will, I believe, pull the party strongly toward the center. Thinking of electoral votes, gaining dominant footholds in Texas, Kansas, Iowa, Georgia, and North Carolina in the Southern and Plains states in 2026 can translate into 84 electoral votes in 2028 -- the entire Northeast base of the party from Maine to Virginia is only twenty more. A 2028 platform towards the hard Left simply will have far too much to lose.
"national politics optimizes around that rigid geographic pattern and falls into a 50-50 deadlock"
Deadlock, yes. 50-50 is only one outcome. From the War of the Slaveholders' Rebellion until 1932, the Democratic Party was largely confined to the Old South, a place almost free of Republicans, meaning that the Republicans usually ran the country.
All well and good, but the noise coming from the newly elected sure seems focused on “gotcha” BS and “everything free for everyone” instead of being responsive to that big center of the populace.
There is much logic in this piece. I also agree that Democrats have MORE work to do here in the end than Republicans do. Like it or not, Donald Trump will not be on the ballot again and Democrat's focus on dislike of Trump personally will NOT overcome their being wrong on many of the issues that actually matter to the median voter.
You discount ideology. Both parties have prioritized that over winning by convincing themselves that the majority aligns with their ideology. The wipeout of the Blue Dogs in the Obamacare election (2010) is an example. The prospect for governance lies in populist fusion to actually solve some problems rather than having the Establishment use the problems for fund raising and then fail to act on solving them.
I don't think the midterms meant anything more, to most voters, than a general tiredness with Trump. Except to the progressives, the midterms did not mean a vote for a massively more active government.
This does not mean that the progressives won't push for their agenda over the next two years. They want to impeach Trump and Hegseth; they want to withdraw immediately from Iran; they want to place a moratorium on data centers and the creation of a government agency to regulate AI; they want universal health care and increased taxes to pay for it; they want to return to DEI and guarantee transgenderism, including allowing surgery for minors; they want to abolish ICE and put a stop to deportations; they want to expand the Supreme Court and eliminate the Electoral College; and so on.
A majority of Americans don't want all this. Most of what the progressives want they won't get, and the more they push their agenda, the stronger the reaction will be. Trump will continue being the President for the next two years and he will not be shy about using the veto.
The clincher will be the Presidential election in 2028. If the progressives push for AOC and she is nominated, the Republicans will win the election. It looks now as if Rubio will be the nominee for the Republicans and he will win. He will not rule like Trump did but more like Reagan did.
Mr. Roeder, I think your second paragraph mixes "progressives" with center-liberal Democrats. The latter would probably want to impeach Hegseth, withdraw from Iran, and create a regulatory agency vis a vis AI. They may also want to reform the Supreme Court (perhaps by expansion, depending on the specific plan) and, of course, abolish the Electoral College, perhaps through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which obviously already has very broad support. (The AI moratorium movement is currently far more of a popular response than one owned by any political faction of either party. I also think that it's unlikely there will be a move to impeach Trump a third time unless and until he acts so flagrantly that conviction appears likely.)
The specifically progressive policies in your list would include universal health care (assuming you mean immediate Medicare-for-All; center-liberal Democrats are obviously in favor of moving towards universal coverage to the degree possible with fiscal integrity) and a return to maximalist DEI. I have no idea what "guaranteeing transgenderism" may mean apart from allowing surgery for minors, but I do think progressives own certain activist positions, such as permitting trans women to compete in women's sports.
I think it's likely that the positions of the Democratic liberal Center currently would be well received by a majority of voters. I think DEI and support for extreme trans medical and social policies would be poison pills for the party. (Less so Medicare-for-All, which I believe could become broadly popular if a plan to phase it in made explicit the trade-offs between necessary higher taxation and relief from private/employer insurance plan costs, and if options for supplementary private plans were allowed as part of an indefinitely long transition.)
From where I sit now, I agree that Rubio would probably win a presidential election against AOC in 2026. Both will be modifying their political profiles over the next two years, and the political winds will shift in ways none of us can predict, so I'm not sure about 2028. I think that among the dozen best known Democratic candidates, well over half are, at this time, better positioned than any known GOP hopeful to win a general election. AOC is currently not the leader in polls of Democratic party member preferences, and I believe that while she has a sizable base of support, candidates more capable of unifying the party are less subject to hitting a hard ceiling below 50% (obviously, Ossoff is currently the model, but I believe others with better chances of reaching party majority support would include Buttigieg, Kelly, Shapiro, the shape-shifting Newsome, among others.
"It certainly moves the ideological center of gravity of our national politics to the left some, but it actually moves the internal ideological centers of gravity of both parties to the right."
I think this is exactly right. In terms of 2028 electoral promise, I believe this will strongly handicap the extreme Left of the Democratic Party--as the DSA seems to have recognized, with dismay--and may strengthen the Groyper-associated wing of the GOP--which is what Fuentes and his supporters seem to believe, with pleasure.
The size of the Democratic wave in Texas and the tremendous rise in influence that this huge state will now have in the party caucus will, I believe, pull the party strongly toward the center. Thinking of electoral votes, gaining dominant footholds in Texas, Kansas, Iowa, Georgia, and North Carolina in the Southern and Plains states in 2026 can translate into 84 electoral votes in 2028 -- the entire Northeast base of the party from Maine to Virginia is only twenty more. A 2028 platform towards the hard Left simply will have far too much to lose.
Just a heads up that Yuval's byline did not appear at the top of the piece in the e-mail newsletter. Good piece!
"national politics optimizes around that rigid geographic pattern and falls into a 50-50 deadlock"
Deadlock, yes. 50-50 is only one outcome. From the War of the Slaveholders' Rebellion until 1932, the Democratic Party was largely confined to the Old South, a place almost free of Republicans, meaning that the Republicans usually ran the country.
All well and good, but the noise coming from the newly elected sure seems focused on “gotcha” BS and “everything free for everyone” instead of being responsive to that big center of the populace.